I’ve start test Houdini 18 and Arnold 6. first test was simple splines rendering, 250.000 splines instanced 25 times. it loads a 140MB alembic file.
rendered in 6 core Xeon CPU and Nvidia Quadro RTX 5000. (windows 10 pro)
the startup for Arnold GPU is slow, it renders faster, so its seems but for clear up the final image it takes for forever or just dropped /crashed, hard to tell on the GPU. the CPU is quite fast but much slower then GPU if it ever would finish. (adaptive sampling was on)
As soon as Arnold finish rendering the scene, it stops and do not refresh any more on parameter changes. so far i am not impressed with the arnold GPU rendering.
here the same scene Arnold CPU with only direct Lighting. (on my macbook)
some test with Arnold GPU. it performed much better with just direct lighting.
I've open a Houdini and rendered with RenderMan 22.6. I used only xrDirectLighting integrator and the render speed was super fast on CPU. I've ditched the Pathertracer for this scene, it gave no visual benefits/improvement in this case. Pure spline rendering, no Polygon meshes.
rendered with Arnold in Houdini. I've tried the atmosphere volumes the first time. easy to setup. The render time was quite slow on the volumes, typically for volumes, but much faster then render the screen environment with VDB cloud. I've used a mesh light for inner character illumination.
it's a shame I could not use Arnold 6 GPU, because of its missing features. Volumes would boost get huge speed boost with volume raymarching on a GPU. I had to use a denoiser from Affinity Photo in dark areas.
I’ve made a simple scene to test the physics of light. for proper light calculation, I used spectral render Indigo and Octane.
Indigo has multiple Engines, standard Spectral Path tracer on CPU or GPU and Bidirectional path tracing with MTL sampling (metropolis Light Transport). Octane has only default Spectral Path tracer on GPU but includes an MTL sampling method. I’v also added Renderman 23 to the test with its unified rendering integrator. It supports bidirectional path, manifold caustics and path guiding on the CPU.
Another render engine like Arnold or Cycles with regular Path tracing would impractical fro complex light calculation tasks.
The base scene is Sphere and squashed Sphere underneath inside a volume box (uniform VDB).
The following image is the result of Indigo Renderer with BiDirectional path tracing and MTL. It was by far the fastest rendering.
This is a quick overview of current render Engines for Houdini and General in terms of MotionGraphics and VFX usage.
There are different RenderEngines out there, each one is unique and uses different method to solve a problem. I am looking into Arnold, RenderMan, Vray, Octane and Redshift. For comparison reason I added Indigo Renderer engine.
There are different way to render a scene with benefits and shortcomings. lets start with most common one.
to be precise Backward Pathtracing. In backward ray tracing, an eye ray is created at the eye; it passes through the viewplane and on into the world. The first object the eye ray hits is the object that will be visible from that point of the viewplane. After the ray tracer allows that light ray to bounce around, it figures out the exact coloring and shading of that point in the viewplane and displays it on the corresponding pixel on the computer monitor screen. that’s classical way, which all of the Render engines uses as standard.
Metropolis light transport (MLT)
This procedure has the advantage, relative to bidirectional path tracing, that once a path has been found from light to eye, the algorithm can then explore nearby paths; thus difficult-to-find light paths can be explored more thoroughly with the same number of simulated photons. Metropolis light transport is an unbiased method that, in some cases (but not always), converges to a solution of the rendering equation faster than other unbiased algorithms such as path tracing or bidirectional path tracing. MetroPolis is often used in Bidirectional mode (BDMLT).
Mix between Path-tracing and MLT, unbiased technique for intelligent light-path construction in path-tracing algorithms. Indirect Guiding that improves indirect lighting by sampling from the better lit or more important areas of the scene. goal is to allow path-tracing algorithms to iteratively “learn” how to construct high-energy light paths.
Regular backward Pathtracing has hard time in indoor scene with small light source because it take lot’s rays and bounce to find a tiny light in a room, just to see if a object gets light by the light.
with Bidirectional, rays are fired from both the camera and light sources. They are then joined together to create many complete light paths.
Unlike most renderers which work with RGB colours, Spectral renderers uses spectral colour throughout, from the physically-based sky model to the reflective and refractive properties of materials. The material models are completely based on the laws of physics. This makes it possible to render transparent materials like glass and water at the highest degree of realism. Spectral renderer are pretty good in simulate different medium atmospheric effects like under water or earth air atmosphere.
hat Biased Render Engine actually means is pre-computing a lot of information before sending out rays from the camera. In more simple words, It uses an optimization algorithm to greatly speed up the render time but doing so It is not strictly just modeling the physics of light but it is giving an approximation